Instructor Guide
Social Justice in Interpreting
An infusion module for Interpreter Education Programs
Created by Dave Coyne and Joseph Hill
This provides an annotated guide to what is included in the module. To see the complete information for the section, scroll down and click on each section title. The module is delivered in different components. Some are intended specifically for instructors, providing information on issues of teaching social justice and facilitating discussions. Sections 1 -5 are designed to be delivered to students. This module was originally created to provide 6 hours of material and activity for a curriculum. We suggest that you use Section 1: Introduction to Social Justice to begin. For Sections 2-5, it is suggested that only 2 of the 4 sections are chosen as part of the course module instead of all sections. Each section may take about 90 minutes to complete. Welcome Letter Insight for Instructors Pre- and Post – Assessment Social Justice Response Paper Section 1: An Introduction to Social Justice Section 2: Using the Addressing Model to Understand Individual Positionalities Section 3: Language Ideology and Attitudes Section 4: Allyship Behavior Development Section 5: Social Justice Discourse Videos Additional Resources for Educators and Mentors Hello, Welcome to the social justice online module. Social justice encompasses the issues of equity and fair treatment with regard to the distribution of wealth, the access to resources and opportunities, and the possession of rights within a society. Interpreters regularly work with people from different ways of life related to cultures, languages, lifestyles, and values. We believe interpreters should always recognize and understand that minority members may or may not want interpreters to be their allies, but nonetheless find themselves working beside interpreting professionals who hold a great number of privileges in society where spoken and aural communication mode is the norm. Just as interpreting is never a neutral act, teaching also demonstrates one’s alliance. Our goal for this module is for interpreter educators and mentors to learn about the needed features to begin implementing topics pertaining to social justice in their classrooms. We believe that we need to work toward a just world, especially for those we work for (and with), and interrupt the cycles of oppression. This means we must address, challenge, and participate in change. Concepts such as culture, identity, communication, power and privilege, supremacy, stereotypes and prejudice, and discrimination and oppression can provide a framework for students to understand differences. We believe that by understanding differences, we move away from myths such as “people are all the same.” Individual differences should be embraced, accommodated for, and celebrated. This is the process of examining our culture and society. Teaching social justice concepts is one of the ways to work toward a just world, but we must warn you that social justice requires a consistent focus and energy that can be difficult and exhausting. It is a lifelong process and requires constant analysis of thoughts, opinions, biases, and behaviors. The work on social justice should not be done in isolation. In addition, we must recognize that a danger with social justice work is a risk of interpreter educators or mentors believing that they can solve the problems of others for them instead of working with the minority members. Due to social justice’s recent increased level of interest and popularity, the risk within the interpreting field is real, especially when it is done without the involvement of minority members. American culture puts more value in self-interest and personal gain over compassion and the common good, and this makes it paramount that people working with minority members learn the legacy of colonialism and other forms of oppression. Social justice work must be equally guided and led by those who experience injustices. This means that privileged members of society must actively seek out and work closely with local community members, specifically interpreters’ stakeholders (e.g., Deaf community members) who have been involved in the social justice movement and are capable of facilitating the discussion on social justice. For interpreter educators and mentors, a great deal of self-assessment and preparation is required before beginning any discussion or lesson about the oppression of minorities. The sociological aspects of people’s lives may be in the form of race, class, ability, language, appearance, sexuality, and gender (only to name a few), and privileged individuals benefit from an aspect of themselves that they may or may not have intended to have. It is vital that social justice conversations are conducted with extreme caution and that examples of minority members’ experiences are discussed with respect and understanding. Creating a one-size-fit-all step-by-step manual would only create a limited framework that runs the risk of ignoring the needs of others. Interpreter educators must be critically conscious when creating well-planned lessons that aim to encourage awareness about people who are different from them. Implementing social justice pedagogy into interpreter programs can benefit interpreting students because they can and do have the ability to increase sociopolitical consciousness, develop a sense of ownership (i.e., agency), and create their own positive social and cultural identity as they learn about the interpreting profession. Social justice is a huge discipline that has courses, majors, organizations, and programs dedicated to it. Working for social justice means you are a change agent; it can be a lifelong process dedicated to leveraging our society for more equitable situations. This module offers a place for educators and mentors to begin the exploration of social justice and we hope you will find the tools provided in this module helpful to you as you prepare to educate our future interpreters to work mindfully with people different than themselves. Ethical behavior and personal responsibility should always be at the heart of these conversations while attention and focus are given to the abilities, needs, and cultural values of others. Warm Regards, To begin, teachers are to review and learn about creating respectful classroom environments. Start controlling emotional triggers by learning about them. Social justice topics may cause emotions to surface. We need to be honest with ourselves and learn what may likely trigger a reaction. We hope you find these resources useful to know before instructors begin social justice discussions. http://www.uww.edu/learn/improving/aboutdiversity/approachdiversity/triggers http://www.mauracullen.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/Navigating-Triggers.pdf This resource provides ways for teachers to establish a safe and engaging classroom environment. http://www.uww.edu/learn/improving/aboutdiversity/approachdiversity/safeclassroom The goal of the pre-/post-assessment is for interpreting students to think about their social characteristics, and what it means to understand and embrace diversity as a professional interpreter. Independent Hours: 45 Minutes The pre/post-assessment is a two-step journal writing exercise for students to compare and analyze their thoughts/opinions about social justice. The pre-assessment portion is the first step of this activity. It may be graded on thoroughness in answering the questions, analysis of issues experienced and observed, and clarity of the paper. Instructors may want students to turn in their original journal (the pre-assessment) as well as the final paper (the post-assessment). Students are to reflect on social justice in terms of what it means to them personally, what it means in the profession of interpreting, and what it means to members of the deaf and hard of hearing community. The students will be given a list of questions as a guide for their reflective exercise. There are no right or wrong answers, but what matters most in this assignment are their sincerity, their efforts, and their willingness to explore the principles and foundation of social justice as it relates to them and the interpreting profession. Every student is different and they have with them their worldviews and their social characteristics that make them who they are and how they interact with individuals and institutions on a daily basis. With this assignment being a pre-assessment paper, the students may not have a necessary foundation to have a solid or exemplary answer on social justice, but that is expected. The students are to write their response paper to answer five of the questions below to the best of their ability. The rubric sample is available for this assignment. The instructors can use the rubric as it is or revise it to suit their preference. How the instructors grade this assignment is up to them (Here is PDF of a sample of a rubric for Reflective Writing.). The instructors can grade the assignment based on timely submission, writing mechanics, and effort. As for the content, the students might earn low marks on the content, but the marks can be used as suggestions for them to improve on their post-assessment paper after completing the social justice module. The students will still have to address the same five questions they used in their pre-assessment paper, but they will answer four more questions to reflect on the changes they made on their paper. Direct link to Assignment Directions for Pre-Assessment: http://www.interpretereducation.org/social-justice/pre-assessment/ You are to write a paper to discuss social justice in terms of how it relates to you as an individual in multiple social dimensions (in terms of race, ethnicity, gender, religion, ability, sexual orientation, sexuality, and et cetera) and how it applies in your future profession as an ASL-English interpreter. This paper should be about 1 page. You should use your own words when writing your paper and give proper citations to sources if you use them in your paper. Please make sure that your paper is submitted on time and that your writing is well-written. Below is the list of questions relating to social justice. Please choose five of the questions and answer them to the best of your ability. Questions: 1. What is your definition of social justice? 2. What is your definition of diversity? 3. How may interpreting organizations hinder and embrace diversity? 4. What characteristics do you possess that make you a diverse individual? 5. What does it mean to be privileged? 6. What is the difference between a right and a responsibility? 7. The dignity of work and the rights of workers means . . . 8. To me, justice means . . . Download PDF of Student Assignment Directions | Download Word version of Student Assignment Directions Direct link to student resource page for this section: http://www.interpretereducation.org/social-justice/intro-to-social-justice/ Link to StreetLeverage article: Link to StreetLeverage article: https://www.streetleverage.com/2014/05/social-justice-an-obligation-for-sign-language-interpreters/ ASL Version: Based on the readings and activities, here are a few suggested follow-up questions: One way to explore why we do what we do is by reflective writing. Ultimately, writing reflective papers encourages students to find what is meaningful to them and thus adds value to their learning. This reflection paper should occur after students have discussed their experience with hardships and injustices, and should be based on Killerman’s suggested icebreaker. Aim to figure out your students’ understanding of Social Justice topics by asking these questions: After this class discussion students are encouraged to reflect on why they want to be an ally as a professional interpreter. At this point, do not focus too much on how this would look; the goal is to further explore the reasons why people want to be change-agents (for themselves? for other groups? for the community at large?). Feel free to invite students to share and articulate their papers in class. Sharing our deeper motives is a level of transparency that builds trust. The more we practice sharing, the more transparent we can become. Papers must follow these guidelines: When writing, consider the following: Optional Follow up Questions: Online Resource for Teachers: Asking Questions to Improve Learning Direct link to student resource page for this section: http://www.interpretereducation.org/social-justice/understanding-individual-positionalities/ Follow-up Readings: Learn how our multiple positionality impacts our lives: Follow-up Questions: Teachers can ask general follow-up questions after their discussions on the above information. Estimated time, 10 Min-15 min Direct link to student resource page for this section: http://www.interpretereducation.org/social-justice/language-ideology-and-attitudes/ Video lecture by Dr. Hill Download PPT for this Lecture | Download PDF version of PPT for lecture Link to article on StreetLeverage: http://www.streetleverage.com/2014/04/marginalization-within-the-sign-language-interpreting-profession-where-is-the-deaf-perspective/ LANGUAGE IDEOLOGY AND ATTITUDES WORKSHEET You are to read a Street Leverage article, “Marginalization Within the Sign Language Interpreting Profession: Where is the Deaf Perspective?” (link: http://www.streetleverage.com/2014/04/marginalization-within-the-sign-language-interpreting-profession-where-is-the-deaf-perspective/). The article is the English translation of the talk given by Nancy Bloch on April 23, 2014 (link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yw1tQwL0FO4). The discussion questions below are based on Nancy Bloch’s talk and Dr. Joseph Hill’s video lecture. Discussion Questions Download PDF of Activity | Download Word version of Activity Direct link to student resource page for this section: http://www.interpretereducation.org/social-justice/allyship-behavior-development/ Readings: Estimated time, 30-40 minutes Student Activity: Discussion Activity: Estimated Time, 20-30 minutes Download PDF of Discussion Guide | Download Word version of Discussion Guide Teacher’s Optional Reading: Nieto, L., Boyer, M. F., Goodwin, L., Johnson, G. R., & Smith, L. C. (2009). Beyond inclusion, beyond empowerment: A developmental strategy to liberate everyone. Olympia, WA: Cuetzpalin. Direct link to student resource page for this section: http://www.interpretereducation.org/social-justice/social-justice-discourse-videos/ All of the videos below come from the following playlist: http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL7PjsZ0VFhctEgtSRR6_dnRG3tQbxyFWj Direct link to video: https://youtu.be/NWjYqJl9xQ4 Direct link to video: https://youtu.be/I93MqF-S-tk Direct link to video: https://youtu.be/jUh6Cm_b3mM Direct link to video: https://youtu.be/LhrflKDGrQY Direct link to video: https://youtu.be/IxKfOjrYfJc Direct link to video: https://youtu.be/i47ZXRR5dLU Here are some general discussion questions when running a group discussion after you watch some of the videos of Deaf community members (and maybe some interpreters). If you would like to have a more in-depth discussion or study a particular issue mentioned in the videos, please refer to the other sections in the online module. Readings for Diversity: (web companion to a textbook of this title) http://www.routledge.com/cw/readingsfordiversity/ Video resources: Articles: Blogs: Books: Download PDF version of Additional Suggestions | Download Word Version of Additional Suggestions The goal of the pre-/post-assessment is for interpreting students to think about their social characteristics, and what it means to understand and embrace diversity as a professional interpreter. Independent Hours: 45 Minutes For the post-assessment, writing a reflection promotes self-awareness and encourages self-assessment. Reflecting on authentic knowledge, practice, and beliefs/attitudes drives the process of developing a sense of professionalism. Reflection allows one to think critically about one’s ability to effectively join content knowledge with practice to reach diverse populations of learners. At the end of the social justice module, it can be expected for students to identify issues; state opinions, inferences, and predictions; and express feelings, beliefs, and attitudes in this post-assessment paper. The students’ responsibility in the self-reflection exercise is to support personal opinion, inference, and prediction by inclusion of relevant content knowledge presented in class. Students are to edit their first pre-assessment paper based on their learning of the social justice topics. The students should show a marked growth in their reflections on social justice with the references to the materials provided in the module. The rubric that is available for the pre-assessment can be used for the post-assessment as well. The instructors are free to use the rubric as it is or revise to suit their preference. In a conclusion of the paper, students are to answer the following four questions in addition to the five questions they have answered. Direct link to Assignment Directions for Post-Assessment: http://www.interpretereducation.org/social-justice/post-assessment/ Edit your first pre-assessment paper based on your learning of the social justice topics. This is an opportunity for you to show growth in your reflections on social justice with references to the materials provided in the module. In the conclusion of this edited paper, please answer the following four questions in addition to the five questions you edited from the Pre-Assessment: Download PDF of Student Assignment Directions | Download Word version of Student Assignment Directions Copyright © 2013-2016 by the National Consortium of Interpreter Education Centers (NCIEC). This NCIEC product was developed by the National Interpreter Education Center (NIEC) at Northeastern University. Permission is granted to copy and disseminate these materials, in whole or in part, for educational, non-commercial purposes, provided that NCIEC is credited as the source and referenced appropriately on any such copies.Instructor guide
Section Overviews
Welcome Letter
Dave and JosephInsight for Instructors
Learning about Emotional Responses (Triggers & Resources)
Creating a Safe and Engaging Classroom Environment
Pre-Assessment Social Justice Paper
Facilitator Instructions for Pre-Assessment
Assignment: Social Justice Response Paper, 1 page
Student Assignment Directions for Pre-Assessment
Introduction to Social Justice: Student Resources
Street Leverage Articles and Videos by Dave Coyne
English Version: Social Justice: A New Model of Practice for Sign Language Interpreters?
http://www.streetleverage.com/2013/09/social-justice-a-new-model-of-practice-for-sign-language-interpreters/ASL Version
English Version: Social Justice: An Obligation For Sign Language Interpreters?
Professional Codes of Conducts and Ethics
Teacher’s Reading:
Follow-up Discussion
Student Paper: Reflection of an Ally
Killerman, 2014.Optional Student Reflection Paper Guidelines
http://itspronouncedmetrosexual.com/2012/05/5-reasons-my-approach-to-social-justice-work-is-better-than-yours/Understanding Individual Positionalities: Student Resources
Watch Prezi Presentation on Addressing Paradigm
Teacher Resources
Language Ideology and Attitudes
Watch Video Presentation
Read the following Street Leverage article:
Activity
Allyship Behavior Development
http://cuetzpalin.com/Cuetzpalin/welcome_files/Ask Leticia Part 1.pdf
http://cuetzpalin.com/Cuetzpalin/welcome_files/Ask Leticia Part 2.pdf
http://cuetzpalin.com/Cuetzpalin/welcome_files/Ask Leticia Part 3.pdfActivities
Download PDF of handout
Social Justice Discourse Videos
Discussion Guide
Teacher Resources
Social Justice Resources Websites:
http://www.ted.com/talks/mellody_hobson_color_blind_or_color_brave
http://www.ted.com/talks/chimamanda_adichie_the_danger_of_a_single_story
http://www.ted.com/talks/sally_kohn_let_s_try_emotional_correctness#t-1033
Other Resources for Download:
Pre- and Post- Assessment Social Justice Paper
Facilitator Instructions for Post-Assessment
Assignment: Social Justice Post-Response Paper, 1 page
Student Assignment Directions